A List to Discuss Advaita Vedanta as Taught by Sri Sankara

srikanta | 1 Nov 2010 12:54

Adwaita and caste system.

Dear Sunil Bhattacharjee.
Iam not trying to establish chronologically the dates of Manu smrthi or
Yanjnavalkya smrthi.I am just pointing out that the social order which was
there in the earlier smrthis have been replaced by other smrthis at later
times,because of the compulsion of social order.For example the
Yajnavalkya smrthi says,"a Brahmin can marry from a Brahmain,kshtriya and
Vaishya kanyas(all from the these three varnas).Is it possible in kaliyuga
at these times.Similarly,a can a widow beget a progeny from the brother of
her deceased husband,without a social stigma attached to her?In olden days
even Nambuthris had such a system,which has been abolished in modern
times.Iam only trying to say that as the society became more and more
civilized,many practices have been given up.That is all.Iam not entering
into a debate on the basis of chronology,as the scholars differ in their
views regarding Mahabharatha,Ramayana,Manu smrthi or Yanjnavalkya smrthi.
Regards,                                             N.Srikanta.

headers

raghavender ganti | 1 Nov 2010 13:27

Re: Adwaita and caste system.

Sri Gurubhyon Namaha
                                      "Iam only trying to
say that as the 
society became more and more civilized"
Have we really become more civilized than what we were????????

Sri Kamakshi
Raghav

________________________________
From: "srikanta@..." <srikanta@...>
To: advaita-l@...
Sent: Mon, November 1, 2010 5:24:53 PM
Subject: [Advaita-l] Adwaita and caste system.

Dear Sunil Bhattacharjee.
Iam not trying to establish chronologically the dates of Manu smrthi or
Yanjnavalkya smrthi.I am just pointing out that the social order which was
there in the earlier smrthis have been replaced by other smrthis at later
times,because of the compulsion of social order.For example the
Yajnavalkya smrthi says,"a Brahmin can marry from a Brahmain,kshtriya and
Vaishya kanyas(all from the these three varnas).Is it possible in kaliyuga
at these times.Similarly,a can a widow beget a progeny from the brother of
her deceased husband,without a social stigma attached to her?In olden days
even Nambuthris had such a system,which has been abolished in modern
times.Iam only trying to say that as the society became more and more
civilized,many practices have been given up.That is all.Iam not entering
into a debate on the basis of chronology,as the scholars differ in their
views regarding Mahabharatha,Ramayana,Manu smrthi or Yanjnavalkya smrthi.
Regards,                                            N.Srikanta.

(Continue reading)

headers

Sunil Bhattacharjya | 1 Nov 2010 16:58

Re: Adwaita and caste system.

Dear Srikantaji,

I am not saying that you are trying to establish chronologically the dates of Manu Smriti and Yajnavalkya
Smriti and there is no need for working on it as it is known that Manu Smriti was the Smriti for the earlier
Yuga than was the Yajnavalkya Smriti. In fact though the Yajnavalkya Smriti was also for the Treta yuga
Vedavyasa gave higher recognition to the Gautama Smriti for the Treta yuga. From your mail the
Yajnavalkya Smriti appeared to have preceded the Manu Smriti and I was referring to that only.

Regards,

Sunil K. Bhattacharjya

--- On Mon, 11/1/10, srikanta@...
<srikanta@...> wrote:

From: srikanta@... <srikanta@...>
Subject: [Advaita-l] Adwaita and caste system.
To: advaita-l@...
Date: Monday, November 1, 2010, 4:54 AM

Dear Sunil Bhattacharjee.
Iam not trying to establish chronologically the dates of Manu smrthi or
Yanjnavalkya smrthi.I am just pointing out that the social order which was
there in the earlier smrthis have been replaced by other smrthis at later
times,because of the compulsion of social order.For example the
Yajnavalkya smrthi says,"a Brahmin can marry from a Brahmain,kshtriya and
Vaishya kanyas(all from the these three varnas).Is it possible in kaliyuga
at these times.Similarly,a can a widow beget a progeny from the brother of
her deceased husband,without a social stigma attached to her?In olden days
even Nambuthris had such a system,which has been abolished in modern

(Continue reading)