headers
Eli Zaretskii | 16 Jun 08:04
Picon

Re: Bidi - will it happen ?


On Sat, 15 Jun 2002, Tim Freedom wrote:

> I'm at a loss here, why is it that qemacs
> 
>   http://fabrice.bellard.free.fr/qemacs
> 
> has been able to include bidi where-as emacs hasn't ?

There's nothing in principle that should prevent Emacs from supporting 
bidirectional editing, except that no one has stepped forward and 
volunteered to do the job.  I'm trying to do that by default, but my 
resources are in short supply lately.

> I know nothing of lisp (let alone elisp), but can't
> the inclusion of fribidi (fribidi.sf.net) be
> incorporated somehow into the emacs code even as an
> external call for the time being (irrespective of
> inefficiency, ugliness, etc - given the user opts for
> its inclusion) ?

We cannot use fribidi (or any other library that requires Emacs to pass 
it a chunk of text to be displayed) because that is incompatible with how 
the Emacsd display engine works.  I explained that several times here; 
you should be able to find the explanation in the archives.

> There is a major disconnect on this topic if one were
> to do any research on it (emacs+bidi that this) on
> google or anywhere else.  m17n.org had claimed that 
> bidi is close at hand (through its various symposiums).
(Continue reading)

Permalink | Reply |
headers
Tim Freedom | 17 Jun 22:05
Picon
Favicon

Re: Bidi - will it happen ?

On Sun, 16 Jun 2002 09:04:53 +0300 (IDT),
  "Eli Zaretskii" <eliz <at> is.elta.co.il> wrote:
> 
> On Sat, 15 Jun 2002, Tim Freedom wrote:
> 
[...]
>
> > There is a major disconnect on this topic if one were
> > to do any research on it (emacs+bidi that this) on
> > google or anywhere else.  m17n.org had claimed that 
> > bidi is close at hand (through its various symposiums).
> > Can't the various interests (m17n, emacs, xemacs, utf2000,
> > etc) unite and have one highly concentrated effort to get
> > this done with ?  Bidi's status is very nebulous at best.
> 
> The principles of bidi support and the general idea how to do it are 
> clear.  What is needed is motivated individuals who wouldn't hesitate
> to study the Emacs display engine code, then hack it to include the 
> bidirectional support.  I'll be more than happy to help such individuals 
> and pass to them what I've written so far; but first I need to see them 
> volunteer and start working seriously.
> 
> In other words, the problem is not the design; the problem is coding 
> (lots of it).  And since the first phase of that coding is to modify the 
> display engine, a person who wants to work on this will have to get a 
> fairly good understanding of how the display works in Emacs.
> 
> > Can we start anew with clear indications of what has
> > or hasn't been done and what is needed to complete the
> > job
(Continue reading)

Permalink | Reply |
headers
Alex Schroeder | 17 Jun 23:26

Re: Bidi - will it happen ?

Tim Freedom <tim_freedom <at> yahoo.com> writes:

> With the various Bidi efforts out there and resident expertise, I don't
> think this issue would fall through the cracks given enough publicity
> about this topic and its needs.  Certainly Handa-san, et al might want
> to re-jump in, no ? :-)

Well, I think all the probable volunteers already know about it,
because it is mentioned from time to time on emacs-devel, for example.

Personally, I would really like the code available for all to see,
download, etc., but since I did not write it, I can not demand it.  :)
Eli has been very helpful in the past, however, so if *you* volunteer,
or bring a volunteer to this list, who will actually do some coding,
then I think you will find all the help you might need.  The point is,
Eli doesn't have the time, I guess, to explain this to people who will
probably not do the coding anyway.  Yes, it is an additional hurdle
for potential newcomers, but I think it is understandable given the
current constraints...  :(

Alex.
--

-- 
http://www.electronicintifada.net/diaries/index.html
http://www.us-israel.org/jsource/US-Israel/hr2506c.html
Permalink | Reply |
headers
Eli Zaretskii | 18 Jun 07:34
Picon

Re: Bidi - will it happen ?


On Mon, 17 Jun 2002, Alex Schroeder wrote:

> Well, I think all the probable volunteers already know about it,
> because it is mentioned from time to time on emacs-devel, for example.

I'd expect that as well.  Also, emacs-bidi is a public mailing list, so 
anyone who is interested can easily subscribe and read what's available.

> Personally, I would really like the code available for all to see,
> download, etc., but since I did not write it, I can not demand it.  :)

I've told in the past that I don't want to publish unfinished code with 
my name all over it.  However, if someone tells me that he/she is 
prepared to actually start working on this, I promise I'll send the code 
and every auxiliary file/info I have that could help.

> The point is,
> Eli doesn't have the time, I guess, to explain this to people who will
> probably not do the coding anyway.

That's true, thanks for the understanding.  Yes, my free time is severely 
limited lately, and will remain limited for the months to come.  I might 
have some break in mid-August and around September, due to public 
holidays, but I'd rather sit and code when I have that time than posting 
more explanations or working on a site dedicated to the issue.

Having said that, I will find time to help, both by discussion and code, 
to anyone who shows a real intent to work on coding the bidi support.
(Continue reading)

Permalink | Reply |
headers
Tim Freedom | 20 Jun 03:17
Picon
Favicon

Re: Bidi - will it happen ?

--- Eli Zaretskii <eliz <at> is.elta.co.il> wrote:
> 
> On Mon, 17 Jun 2002, Alex Schroeder wrote:
> 
> > Well, I think all the probable volunteers already know about it,
> > because it is mentioned from time to time on emacs-devel, for example.
> 
> I'd expect that as well.  Also, emacs-bidi is a public mailing list, so 
> anyone who is interested can easily subscribe and read what's available.

With all due respect, I did a search on google and a few other search
engines in hopes of finding how would a volunteer know/hear of this
forgoing private email.  I did a search on "emacs-devel" and "bidi"
and got virtually nothing (the only detailish mention of emacs and bidi
including status is on this list, for what its worth).  I didn't find
any search abilities specific to either list and so I might be a bit
naive in my thinking, but from my experience no one who hasn't been
previously involved or exposed to bidi in the past would know what bidi
is and/or its requirements.  Furthermore, if the info is presented such
that no Bidi knowledge is required to complete the code, I would guess
a greater deal more people would want to look into this as it would fit
within their knowledge base (ie. they don't have to learn something new).

I went back to emacs-devel (raw text search) for the past 7 months and
saw no mention of Bidi status/help-call.  I'm not refuting your expert
expectations, but what's the harm in making explicit mention of Bidi's
current status and what's required to complete it (again 2-3 sentences
and maybe point at URLs of the posts on where this is discussed) on
emacs-devel and comp.emacs.  At a minimum it would further raise
awareness.
(Continue reading)

Permalink | Reply |
headers
Eli Zaretskii | 20 Jun 08:06
Picon

Re: Bidi - will it happen ?


On Wed, 19 Jun 2002, Tim Freedom wrote:

> > I'd expect that as well.  Also, emacs-bidi is a public mailing list, so 
> > anyone who is interested can easily subscribe and read what's available.
> 
> With all due respect, I did a search on google and a few other search
> engines in hopes of finding how would a volunteer know/hear of this
> forgoing private email.  I did a search on "emacs-devel" and "bidi"
> and got virtually nothing (the only detailish mention of emacs and bidi
> including status is on this list, for what its worth).

Sorry, I don't understand: did your Google search find the emacs-bidi 
list or didn't it?  If it did, then that's all I'd expect: the next step 
is to study the archives of this list.

If Google did NOT find this list, then please tell what words did you use 
in Google.

> I didn't find any search abilities specific to either list

You can search with your Web browser.  Or you can download the archives 
to your local machine and search with whatever tools you have there.

> and so I might be a bit
> naive in my thinking, but from my experience no one who hasn't been
> previously involved or exposed to bidi in the past would know what bidi
> is and/or its requirements.

I don't see how someone who doesn't know what bidi is can help us add
(Continue reading)

Permalink | Reply |
headers
Alex Schroeder | 22 Jun 20:01

Re: Bidi - will it happen ?

Eli Zaretskii <eliz <at> is.elta.co.il> writes:

>> I'm not refuting your expert
>> expectations, but what's the harm in making explicit mention of Bidi's
>> current status and what's required to complete it
>
> Nothing is wrong with that; I simply don't have time and resources to 
> create and maintain such a page.  If someone does that, I'll applaud.

All I know and learned and read I added to the CategoryBidi page on
www.emacswiki.org.  I even added reports about the display of Arabic,
so I think I did what is possible without actually doing the coding
itself.  :)  And since this is a wiki, anybody (not Eli, all the
lurkers on the list) can improve the pages.

Alex.
--

-- 
http://www.electronicintifada.net/diaries/index.html
http://www.us-israel.org/jsource/US-Israel/hr2506c.html
Permalink | Reply |
headers
Eli Zaretskii | 23 Jun 06:43
Picon

Re: Bidi - will it happen ?


On Sat, 22 Jun 2002, Alex Schroeder wrote:

> All I know and learned and read I added to the CategoryBidi page on
> www.emacswiki.org.  I even added reports about the display of Arabic,
> so I think I did what is possible without actually doing the coding
> itself.  :)

That's great, thanks!
Permalink | Reply |
headers
Yair Friedman (Jerusalem | 20 Jun 09:00
Favicon

Re: Bidi - will it happen ?

On Wed, 19 Jun 2002 18:17:57 -0700 (PDT), 
Tim Freedom <tim_freedom <at> yahoo.com> writes:
> I went back to emacs-devel (raw text search) for the past 7 months and
> saw no mention of Bidi status/help-call.  I'm not refuting your expert
> expectations, but what's the harm in making explicit mention of Bidi's
> current status and what's required to complete it (again 2-3 sentences
> and maybe point at URLs of the posts on where this is discussed) on
> emacs-devel and comp.emacs.  At a minimum it would further raise
> awareness.
>

I think the emails Eli reference are these all from mid-January 2001. 

<Pine.SUN.3.91.1010118130031.5194A-100000 <at> is>
<y26ae8pqdvj.fsf <at> chaos.cs.huji.ac.il>
<Pine.SUN.3.91.1010118140124.5194F-100000 <at> is>
<200101190836.RAA07785 <at> etlken.etl.go.jp>
<86g0ifkgg6.fsf <at> gerd.segv.de>

There are other emails around that time that might add more light.
Permalink | Reply |

Gmane