Tomasz Sterna | 5 Feb 22:38
Favicon
Gravatar

Chineese tablets and phones manufacturers violating Linux kernel license

Hello.

Is there anything we can do about the fact, that virtually every Chinese
manufacturer building devices running Android (Tablets and Phones)
violates Linux kernel GPL?

Synrgic, Eanovo, Sidonia, Highton, Lianxintai, Ruyi and on, and on...

Even American companies, like Dell, linger with releasing the source to
they  devices. But Chinese ones just plainly ignore the GPL terms.

This is very frustrating.
One approach is discussed at: http://www.elpauer.org/?p=1146
Is there anything we could do?

--

-- 
Tomasz Sterna
Open Source Developer  http://www.xiaoka.com/portfolio

lkcl luke | 6 Feb 00:02
Picon

Re: Chineese tablets and phones manufacturers violating Linux kernel license

On Sun, Feb 5, 2012 at 9:38 PM, Tomasz Sterna <tomek <at> xiaoka.com> wrote:
> Hello.
>
> Is there anything we can do about the fact, that virtually every Chinese
> manufacturer building devices running Android (Tablets and Phones)
> violates Linux kernel GPL?
>
> Synrgic, Eanovo, Sidonia, Highton, Lianxintai, Ruyi and on, and on...
>
> Even American companies, like Dell, linger with releasing the source to
> they  devices. But Chinese ones just plainly ignore the GPL terms.
>
> This is very frustrating.
> One approach is discussed at: http://www.elpauer.org/?p=1146
> Is there anything we could do?

 *deep breath*.

 there's a company in bristol - i don't know who they are but i have a
friend who knows - who have worked out how to sue companies in China
for Copyright violations across International Boundaries.

 so it *can* be done, but don't for god's sake ask how much they
charge, or how long it takes.  or what the name of the legal firm is.
or for my friend's name.  or his email address.

 the problem that you have in China is that the PRC Govt normally only
takes up Copyright Violation cases for *Chinese Nationals*.  everyone
else can, as far as they're concerned, go f*** themselves.

(Continue reading)

Henrik Nordström | 6 Feb 08:34
Gravatar

Re: Chineese tablets and phones manufacturers violating Linux kernel license

sön 2012-02-05 klockan 23:02 +0000 skrev lkcl luke:

>  to successfully do that, and actually get any damages, however, you
> will *need* to have a "Copyright Registration Certificate".  it
> doesn't matter a damn that you're not even *from* the USA - you
> *still* need to go into a Town Hall in any town in any State of the
> United States, of which there are 51 to choose from (*1), and put in a
> lovely Certificate.

To further complicate matters most developers are not so interested in
getting damages or even compliance, but to educate on the benefit of
cooperating on open source. But getting damages is one way to educate..
just not sure it's a good way.

Regards
Henrik


Gmane