20 Aug 06:22
Hardware compatibility test: draft proposal
From: Wouter Verhelst <wouter <at> debian.org>
Subject: Hardware compatibility test: draft proposal
Newsgroups: gmane.linux.debian.devel.general
Date: 2008-08-20 04:24:07 GMT
Subject: Hardware compatibility test: draft proposal
Newsgroups: gmane.linux.debian.devel.general
Date: 2008-08-20 04:24:07 GMT
Hi, As I mentioned in my blog[1], I kindof like the suggestion that Bdale came up with during Debconf that we write a hardware compatibility test of sorts that hardware vendors could run on their own hardware to test whether Debian works on their system. The rationale for such a test: while most of us know how Debian works and how one should test whether their hardware actually works with Debian, it is not reasonable to expect the same of hardware vendors for /all/ GNU/Linux distributions out there. According to Bdale, currently all other major operating system vendors, including the commercial Linux distributions, already provide such a test to the hardware vendors. For this purpose, it is okay if such a test is interactive to some extent (after all, it is something that you would run on a hardware prototype in a lab, not on each and every production machine), although I'm thinking a hardware compatibility test could be useful in more cases, where it might be better if it wasn't interactive. So, after more than twelve hours of boredom on an airplane and half a night of not-being-able-to-sleep-due-to-jetlag, which is certainly enough to think about this problem, I came up with the following things such a system could need: - It should be modular. People who maintain driver packages for particular hardware may want to write additional tests that a vendor may want to run; and if this particular package supports it, the driver package maintainer may want to provide pointers to a particular package so that an inexperienced user may be able to configure their hardware after running the test themselves. - The different tests should each be able to communicate what type of(Continue reading)

I didn't go into much detail here yet, simply because I feel this is
something we'll have to figure out as we write everything.
> For example, in the case of ethernet adaptors, I feel that simply
> successfully DHCP-ing on an interface is really not an acceptable
> test.
RSS Feed