Aaron Porter | 26 Jul 22:28
Favicon

Defective By Design


	Is it just me, or is it the FSF that seems to have gone defective?
Their latest anti-iPhone campaign[1] crosses some lines I'm not too pleased
with. They're urging people to setup a meatspace denial of service attack
against the "Genius Bars" in Apple Stores world wide in an effort to
educate Apple about it's product is "restricting your freedoms".
	They previously posted "5 reasons to avoid iPhone 3G"[2], a brief
but quite valid list of reasons users might want to avoid the iPhone
(curiously omitting the lack of any support for non-iTunes activation,
use, etc). Their last reason for avoiding the device -- "iPhone is not the
only option." seems to negate the militant tactics they're adopting now.
	I've been a longtime supporter of the FSF (up to but not including
prefixing Linux with GNU), contributing my own time and money as well as
pushing through software "purchases" by my employers. I'm not sure I want
to be associated with the group after this.
	Sure the iPhone is sexy, but there has been sexy hardware for
decades that lacked free software support. I have and continue to "vote
with my feet" -- making purchasing decisions for myself and my employers
based on our ability to use products in the way we desire. I have and will
continue to try to educate others and convince them to do the same. I
don't think I'll every be convinced that deliberately disrupting a legal
business practice and denying a valid service to users who have made
different ethical choices than my own will have a positive result in
freeing anything.

[1] http://www.defectivebydesign.org/apple-challenge
[2] http://defectivebydesign.org/5-reasons-to-avoid-iphone-3g
Rick Moen | 27 Jul 01:14
Favicon

Re: Defective By Design

Quoting Aaron Porter (atporter <at> primate.net):

> Is it just me, or is it the FSF that seems to have gone defective?
> Their latest anti-iPhone campaign[1] crosses some lines I'm not too pleased
> with. They're urging people to setup a meatspace denial of service attack
> against the "Genius Bars" in Apple Stores world wide in an effort to
> educate Apple about [how] its product is "restricting your freedoms".

The FSF go through recurring cycles of either being spot-on in their
public actions or making you shake your head.  It probably depends on
volunteer staffing.

The initiative you cite appears to be that of Matt Lee, "Chief Webmaster
for the GNU Project and Campaigns Manager at the Free Software
Foundation".  

http://mat.tl/ee/
http://groups.fsf.org/index.php/User:Mattl
http://www.advogato.org/person/mattl/
http://identi.ca/mattl
Ruben Safir | 2 Oct 06:29

Re: Defective By Design

On Sat, Jul 26, 2008 at 04:14:41PM -0700, Rick Moen wrote:
> Quoting Aaron Porter (atporter <at> primate.net):
> 
> > Is it just me, or is it the FSF that seems to have gone defective?
> > Their latest anti-iPhone campaign[1] crosses some lines I'm not too pleased
> > with. They're urging people to setup a meatspace denial of service attack
> > against the "Genius Bars" in Apple Stores world wide in an effort to
> > educate Apple about [how] its product is "restricting your freedoms".
> 
> The FSF go through recurring cycles of either being spot-on in their
> public actions or making you shake your head.  It probably depends on
> volunteer staffing.
> 

It might.  I've been personally bitten by that bug where the only
volunteers you can get are truly on the lunatic fringe and do more
damage than help to a cause.

OTOH, this might also emulate directly from Richard.  He's been
increasingly upset with how hardware can restrict users and he might be
just ahead of the curve.  I doubt he'd promote a denial of service
attack either in the Apple Stores on otherwise.

First of all, Richard doesn't believe he has that kind of man power.

Ruben

> The initiative you cite appears to be that of Matt Lee, "Chief Webmaster
> for the GNU Project and Campaigns Manager at the Free Software
> Foundation".  
(Continue reading)

James Morris | 27 Jul 22:21

Re: Defective By Design

On Sat, 26 Jul 2008, Aaron Porter wrote:

> 	Is it just me, or is it the FSF that seems to have gone defective?
> Their latest anti-iPhone campaign[1] crosses some lines I'm not too pleased
> with. They're urging people to setup a meatspace denial of service attack
> against the "Genius Bars" in Apple Stores world wide in an effort to
> educate Apple about it's product is "restricting your freedoms".

Ugh.

If they had any class, they'd set up an apple-haters blog which is so 
compelling that every hilarious post ends up at the top of Digg & Reddit 
next to photos of Martian sunsets.

- James
--

-- 
James Morris
<jmorris <at> namei.org>

Gmane